Five No. 1 MLB Draft Picks Who Didn't Live Up To The Hype
We look at five players drafted first overall that either never made it to the Majors or had a very brief stint in the big leagues.
IBWAA members love to write about baseball. So much so, we've decided to create our own newsletter about it! Subscribe to Here's the Pitch to expand your love of baseball, discover new voices, and support independent writing. Original content six days a week, straight to your inbox and straight from the hearts of baseball fans.
Pregame Pepper
Did you know…
. . . When Mark Appel finally made his MLB debut on June 29, 2022, nine years after being drafted No. 1 overall, he became the oldest first overall pick to debut in the Majors at 30 years and 349 days old.
. . . To date, Appel is the only No. 1 overall pick in the MLB draft to hail from Stanford, although Stanford has produced more first-round picks (23) than any other school in the country and has produced one Hall of Famer, Mike Mussina (drafted No. 20 overall in 1990 by the Orioles).
Leading Off
Five Worst No. 1 Overall Picks in MLB Draft History
By Paul M. Banks
The NFL Draft took place this past weekend, and it was a massive spectacle as always. While none of the other major sports' drafts come remotely close to the NFL in hype and media coverage, the MLB Draft has plenty of drama in its own right. The event began in 1965 -- with Arizona State's Rick Monday becoming the first player to be selected, by the then-Kansas City Athletics.
Only three No. 1 overall picks failed to reach the Major League level. We now present those stories, and two additional picks that also went badly awry.
1. 1991, New York Yankees, Brien Taylor, LHP, East Carteret High School
After a stellar 1993 season in Double-A ball, the Yankees wanted Taylor to head to the instructional league. Instead he went home to North Carolina, where he seriously injured his pitching shoulder in a fistfight. He missed the entire next season and was never the same again.
Long after his baseball career ended, his life took another wrong turn as he was indicted on cocaine trafficking charges in 2012. Taylor was released from prison in 2015.
Notable Stats: Season ERAs after that fateful fight: 6.08 (1995), 18.73 (1996), 14.33 (1997), 9.59 (1998), 27.00 (2000)
2. 2013, Houston Astros, Mark Appel, RHP, Stanford
When Appel joined the Quad Cities River Bandits (you got to love Minor League team names!) in 2013, he made history with Carlos Correa. It marked the first time that two consecutive first overall picks played for the same Minor League team. Appel made it as high as Triple-A, with the Lehigh Valley Iron Pigs (again, Minor League team names!) in the Phillies’ system.
His career appeared to have ended in 2017 as repeated shoulder injuries took their toll, but he did find his way to the Majors for a brief cup of coffee with the Phillies in 2022 when he made six relief appearances and allowed two runs over 10 1/3 innings (1.74 ERA).
Notable Stats: His $6.35 million signing bonus in 2013 is worth $6.99 million in today's money.
3. 2014, Houston Astros, Brady Aiken, LHP, Cathedral Catholic High School
The Astros seem to be as adept at making No. 1 overall selections as they are at playing by the rules. Aiken never signed (becoming the first overall No. 1 not to do so since Tim Belcher in 1983), and re-entered the next year's draft.
Coming off Tommy John surgery, Aiken was selected 17th overall by Cleveland and then struggled for two seasons in their farm system. His career is in doubt after only pitching in two professional games since 2018.
Notable Stat: While Correa is having a fine career, he's the only player of the four selected first overall by Houston to provide them more than one season of Major League service.
4. 1966, New York Mets, Steve Chilcott, C, Antelope Valley High School
Once again, it was a shoulder injury that derailed everything. The only non-pitcher on our list had an injury-plagued career that saw him released by one New York team, and then signed by the other. After baseball, he went into construction.
Notable Stat: After playing 24 games in the Yankees’ organization, he was done with baseball at age 23.
5. 2002, Pittsburgh Pirates, Bryan Bullington, RHP, Ball State
The only member of this list who found a happy baseball ending, albeit in Japan's NPB league. Fans of the Hiroshima Toyo Carp know Bullington as a 2011 Central League All-Star. He won one Major League game (against nine losses); over the Yankees and A.J. Burnett.
Notable Stats: All-Star season with the Carp – 2.42 ERA (sixth best in the league), 13-11 W-L
Paul M. Banks is the Founding Editor of The Sports Bank. He’s also the author of “Transatlantic Passage: How the English Premier League Redefined Soccer in America,” and “No, I Can’t Get You Free Tickets: Lessons Learned From a Life in the Sports Media Industry.” You can find him on X/Twitter at @paulmbanks.